Is Test Optional Real? Can It Hurt NOT to Take the Tests?

The world of college admissions has seen monumental changes over the past few years, and test-optional policies are at the center of this evolution. If you’re the parent of a high school student, chances are you’ve heard about test-optional policies and wondered: What does it really mean? Is it truly optional? And could it hurt my teen if they don’t take the ACT or SAT?

Let’s break it all down so you can feel confident in your decisions about standardized testing—and ultimately set your teen up for success.

First, let’s clarify: Test optional doesn’t mean test blind. Colleges that are test-optional allow students to choose whether to submit standardized test scores as part of their application. However, this choice can have significant implications depending on the institution and your teen's specific circumstances.

It’s worth noting that test-optional policies have existed for decades. Schools like Bates College, Bowdoin College, and Wake Forest University embraced test optional well before the pandemic. However, the COVID-19 pandemic made this policy mainstream, with many colleges temporarily waiving standardized testing requirements.

But here’s what’s happening now: Several schools, especially flagship state universities like the University of Florida, University of Georgia, and University of Miami, are reverting to requiring standardized tests. It’s crucial to know what’s expected from the colleges on your teen’s list and to be prepared accordingly.

The short answer is yes, if possible. Having a test score gives your family options. Even if your teen applies to test-optional schools, they can decide later whether to include their scores in their applications. Without a test score, however, there’s no decision to make.

Here are some key considerations:

• Many merit-based scholarships still require standardized test scores. If your teen doesn’t take the ACT or SAT, they could miss out on significant financial aid.
• Test scores can sometimes strengthen an application, especially if your teen’s GPA or extracurricular profile is less competitive. For example, a strong math score could bolster an application for a STEM-focused program.
• Admissions policies are fluid. Schools that are test-optional today might reinstate testing requirements tomorrow. The earlier your teen takes the test, the more flexibility you’ll have.

You might be wondering: What if my teen isn’t a strong test taker? Should they avoid the stress altogether? Not necessarily. Here’s why:

With the right preparation and support, many students can improve their test scores significantly. Even a modest score increase can make a meaningful difference in the admissions process.

If standardized testing doesn’t align with your teen’s strengths, you can adjust your college list accordingly. Focus on schools where other aspects of their application will shine.

Your teen doesn’t need to take every test or apply to every school. Be selective and strategic in both testing and applications.

Let me share a couple of stories that underscore the importance of making informed decisions about testing:

A family I know decided not to submit their teen’s SAT score to an Ivy League institution. The score was strong, particularly in math, but they assumed the test-optional policy meant the score wouldn’t add value. The student was rejected Early Decision. Now, they’re submitting scores to other schools, but the missed opportunity still stings.

Another family didn’t prioritize testing because they assumed all colleges would remain test-optional. When their daughter’s top-choice school reinstated a testing requirement, she had to cram for the SAT on short notice. The stress was overwhelming, and her score didn’t reflect her true abilities.

Both stories highlight the importance of being proactive and prepared.

Navigating the complexities of college admissions (yes, even without standardized tests!) requires a clear strategy. That’s why I’m inviting you to join The College Application Action Plan, a group coaching program designed specifically for parents like you.

In this program, I work closely with parents and students to:

• Evaluate whether to take the ACT or SAT.
• Develop a personalized testing and application strategy.
• Build a strong college list based on your teen’s strengths.
• Provide actionable feedback tailored to your teen’s unique situation.

You’ll receive professional guidance that eliminates the guesswork and helps your family make confident, informed decisions. Whether your teen is a strong test taker or someone who excels in other areas, we’ll create a plan that positions them for success.

The reality is, college admission is more competitive than ever. Test-optional policies might seem like a relief, but they’re not a free pass. Without a clear strategy, you risk missing critical opportunities—whether it’s gaining an admissions edge, qualifying for scholarships, or simply reducing stress in the application process.

Don’t let your family face the same regrets as others who waited too long to act. Take the first step toward clarity and confidence by joining The College Application Action Plan today.

Ready to Get Started?

Click here to join The College Application Action Plan.