Do Interviews Still Matter in College Admissions?

Today, we're exploring a question that many parents have been asking as their teenagers prepare for college applications: Do interviews still matter?

This is a great question, particularly relevant as college admissions become increasingly competitive and multifaceted. The answer, however, is not straightforward. It depends on various factors, including the type of school and the nature of the interview itself.

Types of College Interviews: Informative vs. Evaluative

When discussing college interviews, it's essential to differentiate between two main types: informative and evaluative.

Informative Interviews: These interviews are primarily an exchange of information. They provide an opportunity for students and parents to learn more about the school, its culture, academic programs, extracurricular activities, and other aspects. The school, in turn, shares detailed information that can help the student make an informed decision about whether it is a good fit for them.

Evaluative Interviews: These are more formal and carry significant weight in the admissions process. An evaluative interview is used by the admissions committee to assess the candidate's suitability for the school. This type of interview can impact the final admission decision, as the interviewer's notes and impressions are often considered alongside the application materials.

Do Interviews Still Matter?

The relevance of interviews in college admissions largely depends on the specific institution. Small liberal arts colleges often place a higher value on interviews compared to larger universities. These schools appreciate the personal touch that interviews provide and use them as a tool to gauge a candidate's fit and enthusiasm for their programs.

For example, a student I worked with had an interview at a small New England school. She went in well-prepared for an evaluative interview, focusing on her activities, summer experiences, and contributions to her school community. Despite her preparation and the positive impression she made, she found the interview more informative. This experience highlights the dual nature of interviews: they are not only about impressing the school but also about the students learning if the school is the right match for them.

The Role of Reciprocity in Interviews

One critical aspect of college interviews is the concept of reciprocity. This means that the interview is a two-way street. Students should not feel like they are merely being “grilled” by the interviewer. Instead, they should see it as an opportunity to ask questions that matter to them and gain insights into the school's environment, culture, and student life.

Encourage your teen to be proactive in these interviews. They should come prepared with thoughtful questions about academics, campus activities, and admissions requirements. This approach not only helps them gather valuable information but also demonstrates their genuine interest in the school.

Preparing for College Interviews

Preparation is key to making the most of college interviews. Here are some tips to help your teen prepare:

1. Research the School: Understand the school's mission, values, programs, and culture. This will help tailor their responses and questions to align with the school's ethos.

2. Practice Common Questions: While each interview is unique, certain questions are frequently asked. Practice responses to questions about strengths, weaknesses, academic interests, extracurricular activities, and career goals.

3. Prepare Questions: Encourage your teen to prepare a list of questions about the school. These could range from specifics about academic programs to campus life and support services.

4. Dress Appropriately: First impressions matter. Dressing appropriately shows respect for the interview process and the institution.

5. Be Authentic: Authenticity resonates with interviewers. Encourage your teen to be themselves, share their true interests and experiences, and express why they are interested in the school.

When Do Interviews Happen?

Timing can vary. Some schools offer interviews before the application is submitted, while others might schedule them post-application. It's important to check each school's specific requirements and timelines. Schools typically release dates for possible interviews on their websites, so make sure to stay updated.

Parents, encourage your teenagers to embrace the interview process as a valuable opportunity for growth and self-discovery. By preparing thoroughly and approaching interviews with confidence and curiosity, they can make a lasting impression on admissions committees.

At Strategic Admissions Advice, we are here to support you and your teen through every step of the college admissions journey. If you have more questions about college interviews or need personalized guidance, don't hesitate to reach out. Schedule a free Discovery Call with us today to learn more about how we can help your teen succeed in their college application process.

Visit callwithsaa.com to book your free Discovery Call.